Cold case: Family, Durham sheriff's still searching for answers in woman's 2005 murder

Rosa Lee Crabtree was killed in her home in November of 2005. The Durham County Sheriff's Office tells WRAL they are now re-examining her murder.
Posted 4/8/2025, 9:47:46 PM Updated 4/9/2025, 12:58:05 PM

IMPACT ON THEM. AND THOSE

AGENCIES AS ALL OF THIS GETS

WORKED OUT.

>> NEARLY 2 DECADES AFTER THE

MURDER OF AN ELDERLY DURHAM

WOMAN. HER FAMILY IS NOW

CONTINUING TO PUSH FOR JUSTICE.

68 YEAR-OLD ROSALIE CRABTREE

WAS STABBED TO DEATH IN HER

HOME IN ROUGE, MONT IN NOVEMBER

OF 22,005. THAT IS WRAL'S

MONICA CASEY SAT DOWN WITH

CRABTREE'S NICE TODAY. SHE

SHARES WHERE THIS CASE STANDS

NOW, 20 YEARS LATER.

>> IT'S KIND OF HARD. ARE WE

LOOKING RIGHT AT THAT PERSON?

WE KNOW THAT PERSON AND ROUGE

NOT WAS IN 2005 AND IS NOW A

QUIET COMMUNITY. THAT PEACE

SHATTERED BY THE MURDER OF

ROSALIE CRABTREE, THE FIRST IN

THAT AREA IN 40 YEARS. WRAL

HAS COVERED THIS CASE FOR

YEARS. SECOND, WHEN SHE

PROBABLY WASN'T 100 POUNDS.

CRABTREE'S NIECE TANYA MILLER

LIVES NEARBY AND SHE LOVED

KIDS. HE WAS INVOLVED IN

CHURCH. SWISS TONIGHT SUNDAY

NIGHT SUNDAY MORNING. SHE TOOK

THE KIDS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD

TO BIBLE SCHOOL. THE 68

YEAR-OLD WIDOW WAS STABBED TO

DEATH WITH A PAIR OF SCISSORS

AFTER COMING HOME FROM CHURCH

FOUND BY HER SON THE NEXT

MORNING. 2 TV'S A DVD PLAYER

AND SOME JEWELRY WERE TAKEN

TO MILLARD. IT STILL FEELS

SENSELESS

>> I KNOW SHE WAS SMART AND

DISABLING OR FOR ANYBODY WITH

SOME MONEY IN THERE AT I DON'T

KNOW. NOVEMBER WILL BE 20 YEARS

SINCE THIS MURDER. THAT'S 2

DECADES WITHOUT CLOSURE.

NOW, THE DURHAM COUNTY

SHERIFF'S OFFICE SAYS THEY ARE

REEXAMINING THIS CASE WITH

FRESH EYES. OUR FAMILY HAS

GRIEVED DEEPLY.

>> ABOUT THIS WONDERED ABOUT

THIS FOR SO LONG.

>> THE KIDS HAVE GROWN UP.

MILLER TELLS ME ALL OF

CRABTREE'S 4 SIBLINGS HAVE

PASSED AWAY WITHOUT KNOWING WHO

KILLED HER. NOW SHE'S LEADING

THE CHARGE TO CLOSE THIS

CHAPTER HAS BEING WITH ALL

>> THESE NEW TOOLS AND THE DNA

THAT MAYBE WE COULD GET SOME

CLOSURE AND

>> AT SOME STUFF OUT MAIL THAT

THEY DIDN'T HAVE. BUT THEN

BECAUSE I KEEP SEEING ALL THESE

COLD CASES SOLVED IN DURHAM,

MONICA CASEY, WRAL NEWS.

YEAH. AND IN A STATEMENT,

DURHAM COUNTY SHERIFF CLARENCE

BIRKHEAD SAID IN PART, QUOTE.

>> AT THE TIME OF HER DEATH

SHERIFF'S OFFICE DETECTIVES

CONDUCTED A THOROUGH

INVESTIGATION, HOWEVER, WITH

THE ADVANCEMENT OF TECHNOLOGY

AND FORENSIC SCIENCE, THERE MAY

BE NEW WAYS TO LOOK AT THIS

CASE.

>> HE'S ENCOURAGING ANYONE WITH

INFORMATION TO CONTACT THEM.

WE HAVE THE NUMBER FOR THE