Chaos erupts when Lee County deputies detain wrong person at funeral in 30-year-old cold case

Lee County deputies believed a man linked to a 1995 murder in Sanford was in attendance at a funeral at a local cemetery. Another man was detained, leading to confusion and hostility with attendees.
Posted 5/20/2025, 8:58:07 PM Updated 5/21/2025, 12:58:07 AM

>> NUMBER ONE SOURCE FOR LOCAL

NEWS. THIS IS WRAL.

>> CHAOS AT A PLACE OF MOURNING

LEE COUNTY DEPUTIES THIS

EVENING ARE FACING INTENSE

CRITICISM AFTER THEY TRIED TO

ARREST A MAN DURING A FUNERAL.

THEY BELIEVED HE WAS TIED TO A

MURDER NEARLY 30 YEARS AGO,

BUT TURNS OUT IT WAS THE WRONG

GUY. THANKS FOR JOINING US.

I'M LENA TILLETT AND I'M DAN

HAGGERTY. THE WHOLE THING WAS

CAUGHT ON CAMERA. THIS IS A

PORTION OF THE VIDEO HERE.

>> YOU SEE THIS IS GATHERED.

HUNDREDS OF USED ONE OF THE

DEPUTY MOVES AND THE MAN

GETTING OUT OF THE VEHICLE

THERE WHILE IN HANDCUFFS WRAL'S

CARLY HAYNES HAS BEEN LOOKING

INTO THIS FOR US. CARLY IKE, I

CAN ONLY IMAGINE HOW THE PEOPLE

THE FAMILY INVOLVED IN THIS

FEELS ABOUT THE WHOLE THING.

>> UPSET AND THEY ARE CONFUSED.

THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE SAID THEY

WAITED FOR THE FUNERAL TO END

AND THEN TRIED TO STOP THE

CROWD AS THEY WERE COMING FROM

THE CEMETERY OVER TO THE

PARKING LOT.

>> IT STARTED AS A FUNERAL

SERVICE AND ENDED LIKE THIS.

>> IT WAS MOST RIVERS BY I WAS

SAYING YOU'VE EVER BEEN TO A

KID. HE TOOK THIS VIDEO CROWD

TRIES TO STOP A LEE COUNTY

DEPUTIES FROM BRINGING SOMEONE

INTO CUSTODY. THE TIME OUT WILL

YOU WONDER IS WE'VE GOT TO WANT

TO RAISE.

>> WE THANK YOU KNOW WHY YOU

GOT WHAT YOU GOT A WARRANT FOR

HIS ARREST.

>> THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE GOT

TIPS THAT WILLARD SMITH, THE

SUSPECT OF A 1995 MURDER MAY BE

IN THIS CROWD. THEY DETAINED

SOMEONE, THEY SAY MATCHED HIS

DESCRIPTION ULTIMATELY FINDING

IT WASN'T THE SUSPECT. IT WAS

HIS BROTHER. WE NEVER WANT TO

UPSET A FAMILY OR DO ANYTHING

TO DISRESPECT ANYONE THAT WE

HAD TO GO. CHECK THAT OUT TO

SEE IF WE CAN LOCATE HIM.

>> I KIND OF FEEL LIKE IT WAS

OUR ONLY OPPORTUNITY. SHERIFF

BRIAN ESTES SAID GOING HERE WAS

A CHANCE TO CLOSE A 30 YEAR-OLD

CASE. DID YOU THINK YOUR

DEPUTIES HANDLED IT

APPROPRIATELY THAT THINGS WERE

DONE AS THEY SHOULD HAVE BEEN?

I FEEL LIKE THEY DID WHAT THEY

COULD DO TO STAY SAFE AND THEY

KEEP EVERYONE FROM GETTING

HARMED.

>> THE SHERIFF'S OFFICE SAID

THE PERSON WHO THEY DETAINED

FULLY COOPERATED WITH THE

INVESTIGATION. THE SHERIFF'S

OFFICE IS ALSO OFFERING A

$10,000 REWARD FOR ANYONE WHO

MAY HAVE INFORMATION THAT LEADS

TO THE SUSPECT'S ARREST.

CARLY HAYNES, WRAL, NEWS LIVE